“When you buy a tool, buy the best, and then you only buy it once.” – Dale Albers, Journeyman Plasterer, Friend and Mentor
I was 14 years old and the tool I held uncomfortably in my hand had long ago been relegated to the bottom of a pick-up truck tool box; the dark and dusty graveyard where old trowels with rusted blades and popped rivets go to die. You see plasterers very rarely throw away their old trowels; they just put them out to pasture. A quality built trowel will serve its purpose for many years, even decades if cared for properly.
But sometimes a trowel accidentally gets knocked off the scaffolding or someone neglectfully lays a mud board or a piece of scaffolding down on a trowel inadvertently left in the back of a truck. Even these “walking wounded” will generally make their way to some useful purpose, (i.e. scraping floors, cut into midget trowels) and some will even fall into the hands of young bucks who think they want to make their living in this physically demanding trade.
There are two categories of trowels: those that are made for professionals and those that are made to sell to do-it-yourselfers who will use the tool once or twice in a lifetime.
Trowel Anatomy 101
There are four basic components to a well-made trowel:
Carbon steel produces a strong, lightweight, and flexible blade, however they are prone to rust and pitting if not carefully dried and stored after the work is done. Stainless steel is an alloy of carbon steel, chromium, nickel, manganese, and other trace materials that make it impervious to rust. (Some say that stainless steel and cockroaches will be the only things to survive a nuclear holocaust.)
The drawback to stainless steel is that it is a little heavier and less flexible. Golden stainless steel is easily recognized by the coppery-golden color, a byproduct from heat-treating ordinary stainless steel. The tempering or “annealing” process is used to harden the steel, improve its abrasive resistance and fortify its strength after its been subjected to the drilling and stamping of the manufacturing process. The advantages of a golden stainless are the same as a normal stainless steel blade but due to the strengthening benefits of heat-treating, a thinner blade can be used which reduces weight and increases flexibility.
The shank is what links the blade to the handle. It is comprised of a long narrow “spine” that lies flat down the middle and on the backside of the blade; the “neck” that traverses the space between the blade and the handle; and the “stem” that protrudes through the handle and to which the handle is attached. The shank of a professional trowel is made from cast aluminum or an aluminum alloy. This creates a part that is both lightweight and strong. The length of the “spine,” as it lies along the trowel blade, will greatly determine the flexibility or rigidity of the trowel. Pool trowels, which are designed to be very flexible so they can work around radiuses, have a very short spine; trowels used for high-end interior finish work tend to have a longer spine to maintain as flat a wall as possible.
The handle of a trowel is made from hard wood, usually basswood, or a more modern contrivance called a “soft-grip” made of synthetic rubber. The wood handles remain the more popular among plasterers. Wood handles come straight or shaped with a curve, which is commonly referred to as a “camel-back” or “California-style” handle. These curved shape handles are far more popular and allow a more comfortable and natural grip. I polled several veteran plastering instructors from across the country and found two primary reasons for their choice of wood over soft-grip:
A) They like the smooth feel of wood over some of the soft-grip handles that have a seam or joint in them. This preference is probably driven more in plastering over the other trades because of the unique manipulation of the trowel turning in the plasterers hand as he changes direction and from application on the wall to loading his hawk.
B) One hundred percent of those I surveyed said that they always customize their handle as soon as they get it, using a rasp, file and sand paper. I guess if it worked for grandpa, as smart and hard as he worked, it will work for me.
The blade of the trowel is attached to the spine of the shank with rivets. The rivet can protrude partially into the shank or all the way through it, the benefit and practice of these choices differs slightly even among the leading manufacturers. One leading manufacturer uses slightly smaller rivets than some others to reduce weight but adds a larger headed rivet at the “toe” end because this is where most rivets will fail (the “toe” is the front or leading edge of the trowel, while the “heel” is the back or trailing edge). The same manufacturer also chooses to drive the rivet pin all the way through the shank because their experience has shown this to be a stronger fastening of the parts. The face of the blade is ground to finish off the rivet heads to be flat with the blade surface; if care is not taken and the grinding is too deep, this will weaken the rivet head causing it to pull through the blade metal prematurely. The rivets of a well-made trowel will hold the blade tightly to the shank over many years of daily use.
Care and Maintenance
Breaking in a new trowel is a periodic requirement for all good plasterers. Most will begin by using the trowel to spread the scratch and brown-coats of plaster, which really don’t require a trowel blade that has been worn to the “sweet-spot.” This allows them to fine tune the shaping of the handle and break in the blade, and to see how the components, especially the rivets, hold up. Once the trowel feels comfortable to the hand and the blade begins taking on a good “set,” a natural and very slight concaved curve, it is only then considered a very valuable tool.
Most plasterers will have several trowels of the same size all in various stages of the break-in process; some they use for scratch and browning, and others they use for interior or exterior finish work. Some of these that have been taken care of and used daily will wear down by 10 to 20 percent of their original width over a lifetime of use.
Unless a trowel is damaged by abuse or neglect, it is the rivets that will give out long before the blade, shank or handle will wear out. You can extend the life of a trowel by only using it as it was intended and refrain from using it as a scraper and pulling the blade backwards, as this causes undue stress on the rivet connections.
Interior finish plastering requires a perfectly smooth edge; some say a “razors-edge.” If you think a box cutter is sharp, try (carefully) feeling the edge of a plasterer’s finish trowel sometime. As the trowel is used to spread and polish the wall surface, the metal eventually will begin to wear. The square cut edge will give way to a beveled knife-edge, and eventually the metal will become thin and easily nicked. Once the edge has been worn to the sweet-spot, you want to try and keep it there and not allow it to become too thin. The prudent use of a fine metal file, held perpendicular with the blade edge, and run down the edge like a carpenter planing the edge of a door, and a couple of careful swipes with some fine emery cloth, will ensure the edge of the blade remains straight and nick-free.
Keeping the trowel clean is just a matter of common sense. A dirty trowel, even one with just a tiny bit of build up on the shank, is heavier than a clean trowel. And when you consider the many hours a plasterer spends with trowel in hand, even a quarter ounce of extra weight contributes to the wear and tear on wrists and elbows over time. The best method to ensure a tool is kept clean is to make it part of your workday routine. Always take a few minutes to scrape and clean off all of the material from the tool at the end of the day. Lay it flat on the ground and with a little water and sand, run a margin trowel laid flat, back and forth on the back side of the blade (this and the shank are where most build up accumulates) until all of the color is gone and there is nothing but shiny bright metal. Your joints and muscles will thank you.
If you educate yourself about the options, you can keep a quality product clean and well maintained. The trowel you buy today will not only serve you well each and every day, but it may very well find its way into the hand of some young buck yet to be born. W&C
I wish to thank the following for their contributions to this topic.
- Steve Cook, Kraft Tools www.krafttool.com
- Tim Brennecke, Marshalltown Co. www.marshalltown.com
- OPCMIA Plastering Instructors: Sam Prince (Wash.), Kevin Gordo (Pa.), Wimlish Owens (Ga.), Marty O’Brien (Mass.), Tim Nelson (Calif.), Fred Gallimore (Okla.), Rick DalPazzo (Mo.), Raul Montoya (Ariz.), Maybell Hartness (Idaho), Jimmy Obergon (Nev.), Kyle Sparkman (Ohio), Dan Jackson (Va.), David Woods (Calif.), Laura Johnson (Ore.), Jerry Shelton (Calif.), Nicho Garcia (Texas), Gene Neville (Ohio), and Sammy Stuart (Ark.).